Binge Eating Forum » Binge Eating Support - General Comments, Questions, and Posts

A lot of questions!

(8 posts)
  • Started 1 year ago by kirsten.stang
  • Latest reply from alannah09
  1. kirsten.stang
    Member

    Hey everyone!

    Just joined onto the site today.. I guess I'll start by saying I've been yo-yo dieting for about three years now.. Every time I lose 15 pounds I end up gaining 25 back. I never understood why I did it until recently when I was browsing around online and found a couple sites that taught me about binge eating. Then I was like THAT'S TOTALLY ME! Hiding in my room to eat, "stuffing" food in my face late at night when I know I'm not really hungry.. all the rest..

    I still do not know very much about binge eating. Does it ever completely go away? What is the best way to go about losing weight, because the regular eating healthy/exercise thing will work for a couple months tops but then I go back to binging! I still do not know why I do it and I think of myself as a very optimistic, laid back, happy person.. I don't feel extremely emotional or depressed and I rarely get stressed out?

    By the way, this is the first time I have ever talked to anybody about it. I greatly appreciate any feedback

    Posted 1 year ago #
  2. kirsten.stang
    Member

    I did a little more reading around after I posted that last message and I think I know what steps I need to take to start getting over this. I kept on reading that the best thing to do is journal as well as have somebody to talk to. Well I figure this is the best place to do that! I feel like if I write out what I eat and what I'm feeling that it will make me more aware of what I'm putting into my body and I can start figuring out what makes me binge. I tend to quit a lot of things and my mind keeps saying, "you're not going to be able to really go through with this!" I want to prove myself wrong and I really need to start living my life healthier and I want to be able to feel comfortable in my own skin. So today I woke up with great intentions! But something I got confused about right away is whether i should eat breakfast if I'm not hungry. I know you're not supposed to eat if you're not hungry.. but I also know you're supposed to eat breakfast. So what do I do? Well, I drank a cup of fruit & veggie juice. Then I started to feel a little bit hungry and I ate a bunch of cookies. Good breakfast.... I don't know what feeling led me to eat those cookies.. but I do know that I was telling myself that I had to get rid of the temptation.. That's an absolutely rediculous thing to think! It makes no logical sense. But I'm going to try really hard not to let that "ruin" the rest of my day.. Cause one thing I do very often is tell myself that well I ate bad today anyways, might as well eat bad some more.. it's not going to make a difference. Even though I know that it does.. But another thing I need to work on is figuring out which feelings cause me to binge, cause I'm still not sure...
    Keep ya posted!

    Posted 1 year ago #
  3. eniarrol
    Member

    hi kirsten, i used to weigh 47kg, then i got fed up at always thinking 'this dress would look perfect on me if only my arms were slimmer/more toned' and so on, so i was determined to lose all that weight. i got to 38kg, and my friends started commenting i was 'bony' which was definitely not what i wanted. i wanted a lean body with good muscle tone. so i decided to go easy on food and it got overboard. i got up to 50kg(!!!) and was so upset with myself. that happened in around 4-5 months. it was a nightmare and i'm in first year in university and studying for the final exams with binging was crazy. i tried to stop but i just couldn't. so i thought, maybe it's just the exams.

    but it wasn't. when the exams were over, i binged more than ever. it wasn't celebratory or anything, just plain eating numbly. i wasn't stressed anymore but i kept going.

    i would advise you to really, really try different things to find out what the trigger is. 1) it's a habit 2)there's a trigger. these are the 2 things. based on my personal experience only, of course. for me, 2)my trigger was being out of control. i hated the way i studied without a plan. and when i made a plan which i couldn't follow, i got stressed out. after the exams, i played computer games, watched tv, and never had a plan. i discovered that i was happy at that instant i played games (and binged, haha), but at the end of the day, i wondered about what i was doing with my life. i wanted to be more accomplished and have a proper plan which i'm happy about each day.

    i bought a journal and outlined everything. i set a realistic goal weight for myself and also a realistic plan to get there. e.g. even though i had loads of time after my exams and could work out for hours, if i wanted to reach my goal weight quickly but not over-stress myself, i would work out for an hour, take a break, do other things, then work out for another hour at night. working out say,3 hours at one go was plain unrealistic. i used to plan my days that way and couldn't make it, of course. then i got upset with myself, and binged. looking back, duhhh i was just leading myself to a binge!

    so i think if you really figure out your trigger, you'll realise that hey, you are leading yourself to that binge.

    the other thing which i mentioned, which is binging out of habit, is equally true. don't be too hard on yourself and slowly lessen your binges. you may overeat a little but do that in moderation. soon you'll be able to cut down on overeating and you'll realise that you don't need much food for each meal to begin with.

    i'm now 42kg and so much happier with myself. i can't even SEE myself binging on all those foods i used to binge on. it's useless to me now. the craving isn't even there. i hope that gives you some motivation! it takes time, but be patient with yourself when changing your unhealthy eating habits. (try changing, not cutting out. replace it with an activity right after your meal, for instance. i found it to be easier that way.) then also take time to identify your trigger. journal your thoughts as you make your progres each day. good luck!!!

    Posted 1 year ago #
  4. Nicole
    Member

    Hi Kirsten,

    Im a newbie too..

    This is the first time i've spoken openly about this too and I feel the same as you.. word for word!
    I really hope this works for us all. If we keep chatting and try to work out our emotions before we binge, hopefully it'll work.

    Posted 1 year ago #
  5. kirsten.stang
    Member

    The past few days I have been really trying to figure out what triggers my binges. I think once I have that down I will be able to start controlling it. A lot of the foods I tend to binge on are ones that make me feel happy at the time when I'm eating them, such as chocolate! Eniarrol, what you said about eating out of habit I realized that is totally true for me. I also eat and binge when I'm bored. So I think mainly I binge for comfort reasons. Does anyone else feel like they binge because it's what's familiar and comfortable? I also realized that the past few days, since I'm trying to be more aware of my feelings and what I am eating, I can't get food off of my mind. I think about food all day long. Am I hungry? Or not? What should I eat for lunch? What should I eat for dinner? Am I hungry now? What am I craving? It's annoying and I hope someday I can get to the point where eating healthily and only when I'm really hungry becomes a habit and I don't need to think about it constantly. Nicole, I have only been journaling and going at this for four days now and I think I already found the main triggers for binging and I feel like that's a big step. I hope that gives you some encouragement. Getting out my feelings and questions definitely is helping! Keep posting!

    Posted 1 year ago #
  6. Hope777
    Member

    Hey Kristen! I def. felt like i binged in the past because it was familiar and comfortable. Over the last month i have been trying hard pin point when i am hungry and when it is just a craving. At first i didnt know how much i should be eating. So i looked up how many calories i should eat (around 2000) and tracked it everyday. Before i would be eating too many or too little calories. After doing this for a couple weeks i kind of got used to how many calories i should be eating and am now able to think less about when i should eat/ what i should eat. My binges have become less and less because i am eating the right amount of calories and i can pin point my triggers (usually). Hope this helps! :))

    Posted 1 year ago #
  7. Nicole
    Member

    Hi Hope777,
    Its great to count cal;ories for your body needs, but i found it became obsessive with me, i could actually quite acurately guess how many calories in any given food, and i'd start to count silly things like grapes..

    Maybe it's better to do what andrew suggests by 'mindfull eating' where you slow downa dn your body will tell you when youve had enough..

    I can do this breaky and lunch and it all goes wrong after that.
    Most of it is habbit though as sometimes i dont feel down but still really crave food, so i'm starting to think about awful events that happened in my past.. am i making excuses or can these things really affect me now!?

    Posted 1 year ago #
  8. alannah09
    Member

    I think the mindful eating is a great idea if you can really trust yourself to be mindful, which is extremely difficult for newbies to regular eating. The whole point of our problem is that we know when we are full, and basically choose to ignore it whether the reason is emotional, because one is bored, or whatever. The goal would definitely be mindful eating but I think a general range is helpful in the beginning. Not talking count every grape, just shoot for a general range. Without keeping careful track, if you stick to regular meals and try to eat, say, 5-400cal meals everyday, if you have 350 at one and 450 at the other its not a big deal, and its easy to keep track of 5 little number in your head or on paper or in your phone or whatever. Having the range has seemed to help me a lot.

    Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.